Why Your Top Sales Performer Might Not Make the Best Sales Manager

In sales, it's often tempting to reward your top performers with promotions to management positions. After all, if they're stellar at selling, they must be great at leading a sales team, right? Not necessarily. Your top sales performer might not be your best sales manager. This common misconception often leads to a classic example of the Peter Principle in action, where individuals are promoted to their level of incompetence.

The Peter Principle, coined by Dr. Laurence J. Peter, states that employees tend to rise in an organization until they reach a position where they are no longer competent. In sales, this frequently manifests when top salespeople are elevated to management roles without considering the stark differences in required behavioral traits.

Contrasting Traits: Salespeople vs. Sales Managers

Successful salespeople often exhibit traits such as:

1. High competitiveness

2. Strong individualism

3. Resilience to rejection

4. Persuasiveness

5. Focus on short-term wins

   
   

On the other hand, effective sales managers typically possess:

1. Coaching and mentoring abilities

2. Strategic thinking skills

3. Team-oriented mindset

4. Emotional intelligence

5. Long-term planning capabilities

   
   

The disconnect between these trait sets can lead to significant challenges when a top salesperson transitions to a managerial role. They may struggle to shift from an individual contributor mindset to one focused on team success. The very traits that made them exceptional salespeople – like a fierce competitive drive – might hinder their ability to nurture and develop a diverse team of sales professionals.

Moreover, the skills that contribute to closing deals don't necessarily translate to the ability to inspire, guide, and manage others. A sales manager needs to be adept at delegation, performance evaluation, and strategic planning – competencies that aren't typically honed on the sales floor.

The Solution: Behavioral Assessments

To avoid falling into the trap of the Peter Principle and ensure you're placing the right people in leadership positions, consider implementing validated behavioral assessments for all sales manager candidates. These assessments can provide valuable insights into a candidate's potential success in a managerial role by evaluating traits such as:

1. Leadership aptitude

2. Coaching abilities

3. Collaborative tendencies

4. Strategic thinking capabilities

5. Emotional intelligence

   
   

By utilizing these tools, you can objectively evaluate whether your top salesperson has the behavioral traits necessary for success as a manager. You might discover that another team member, or even an external candidate, is better suited for the position.

It's crucial to remember that being an excellent salesperson and being an effective sales manager are two distinct skill sets. By recognizing this difference and using behavioral assessments to inform your promotion decisions, you can avoid the pitfalls of the Peter Principle and set your sales team up for long-term success.

This approach doesn't mean you should never promote top performers. Instead, it emphasizes the importance of making informed decisions based on behavioral traits rather than solely on sales performance. For those star salespeople who don't exhibit managerial traits, consider creating alternative career paths that allow them to continue excelling and being rewarded without taking on leadership responsibilities they may not be suited for.

By aligning behavioral traits with job requirements, you can build a stronger, more effective sales organization where both individual contributors and managers thrive in their respective roles.

Learn More About Hire Capacity's Assessments

www.hirecapacity.com