top of page
Writer's pictureHarry Lakin

When Hiring Leaders Get a "Second Opinion"


hiring leaders

Think of hiring a senior leader like undergoing major heart surgery. You wouldn't choose a surgeon based solely on their charming bedside manner, would you? You'd want someone with proven expertise, a steady hand, and the ability to handle complex situations. Similarly, relying solely on resumes and interviews when hiring for leadership roles can be incredibly risky. That's where the value of an objective "second opinion," like a behavioral assessment, comes in.


The Limitations of Traditional Hiring Practices:

Just like a pre-op assessment is crucial before surgery, a deeper dive into a candidate's behavioral tendencies is essential for successful hiring. Traditional methods, like interviews, can be swayed by:

  • Subjectivity:  First impressions and "gut feelings" can be misleading. We all have unconscious biases that influence our judgment.

  • Rehearsed Responses:  Candidates often come prepared with polished answers and well-crafted narratives that may not reflect their true work style.

  • Focus on Skills over Fit:  Resumes highlight technical skills, but fail to reveal how a candidate will navigate leadership challenges, manage stress, or interact with their team.


Behavioral Assessments: The Objective "Second Opinion"

Much like an MRI provides a detailed picture of a patient's heart, behavioral assessments offer valuable insights into a candidate's:

  • Leadership Style:  Do they empower their team or micromanage? Are they collaborative or autocratic?

  • Decision-Making: Are they analytical and data-driven, or intuitive and risk-taking?

  • Communication Style: How effectively do they communicate, listen, and provide feedback?

  • Emotional Intelligence: How well do they understand and manage their own emotions and those of others?


These insights help you understand if a candidate's behavioral tendencies align with your company culture and the specific demands of the role.


Benefits of Using Behavioral Assessments:

  • Reduced Hiring Risk:  By providing a more holistic view of a candidate, assessments help you make informed decisions and avoid costly hiring mistakes.

  • Improved Cultural Fit:  Identify candidates who are not just skilled, but also a good fit for your organization's values and work environment.

  • Enhanced Team Dynamics:  Understand how a candidate will interact with their team and contribute to a positive and productive work environment.

  • Objective Data:  Assessments provide data-driven insights, minimizing the impact of personal bias in the hiring process.


Beyond the "Second Opinion"


Just as a surgical team relies on multiple tools and expertise, the best hiring decisions are made using a combination of methods. Behavioral assessments should complement your existing process, providing valuable data to inform your interviews and reference checks.


When hiring for critical senior roles, don't rely on gut feeling alone. Integrate behavioral assessments into your process to gain an objective "second opinion" and make data-driven decisions that lead to long-term success.





Harry Lakin, Hire Capacity
hirecapacity.com

2 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page